xAnts

Synology's SNV5400 SSDs: Premium Price for Outdated Tech – Are They Worth It?

heise

Synology, a name synonymous with reliable Network Attached Storage (NAS) solutions, has recently launched three new SSDs: the SNV5400 series. While NAS devices are increasingly relying on SSDs for performance boosts, concerns are rising about the pricing and underlying technology of Synology's latest offering. Are you getting your money's worth, or are you paying a premium for older tech?

The SNV5400 Series: What's the Deal?

The SNV5400 series consists of 240GB, 480GB, and 960GB SSDs, specifically designed for use in Synology NAS devices. Synology heavily promotes these drives as the optimal choice for achieving peak performance within their ecosystem. However, a closer look reveals that these SSDs utilize a 3D NAND architecture that's already considered somewhat dated in the broader SSD market. While perfectly functional, they don't incorporate the latest advancements like 176-Layer 3D NAND or PCIe 4.0 support found in competing drives.

The Price Point: A Significant Concern

The biggest point of contention is undoubtedly the price. Synology's SNV5400 SSDs command a significant premium compared to similarly sized third-party SSDs. This price difference is particularly noticeable when considering that the technology itself isn't cutting-edge. Users are questioning why Synology is charging such a high price for older technology, especially when more modern and affordable alternatives are readily available.

Why the Push for Synology SSDs?

Synology's motivation is likely multifaceted. Firstly, controlling the hardware within their NAS ecosystem allows them to optimise performance and ensure compatibility. They can tailor firmware and system settings specifically for their SSDs, potentially leading to a smoother user experience. Secondly, it's a lucrative revenue stream. Selling SSDs alongside their NAS devices significantly increases their overall profit margins. Finally, they can guarantee a certain level of quality and support, though this comes at a premium cost.

Are There Alternatives?

Absolutely. Numerous third-party SSD manufacturers offer excellent alternatives that provide comparable (or even superior) performance at a lower price point. Drives utilizing newer NAND technology and faster interfaces like PCIe 4.0 can offer noticeable speed improvements, particularly for demanding workloads like video editing or running virtual machines. While compatibility should always be a consideration, many modern SSDs work flawlessly within Synology NAS devices.

The Verdict: Proceed with Caution

While the Synology SNV5400 SSDs are undoubtedly functional and optimised for Synology NAS devices, the high price and outdated technology raise serious questions. For users on a budget, or those seeking the absolute best performance, exploring third-party alternatives is highly recommended. Before investing in Synology SSDs, carefully weigh the benefits of ecosystem integration against the significant cost premium. Consider your specific needs and usage patterns to determine whether the SNV5400 series truly justifies its price tag.

Ultimately, the decision rests with the individual user. However, it's crucial to be aware of the trade-offs involved before committing to Synology's premium SSD offering.