Cold Case Breakthrough: DNA Technology Could Link Notorious Criminal to 1974 St. Cloud Sisters' Murders

2025-07-05
Cold Case Breakthrough: DNA Technology Could Link Notorious Criminal to 1974 St. Cloud Sisters' Murders
Duluth News Tribune

A Chilling Cold Case Reopened by Cutting-Edge DNA Technology

Central Minnesota is once again grappling with a decades-old mystery as new DNA technology offers a potential breakthrough in the 1974 murders of two St. Cloud sisters. The case, which haunted the region for years, is receiving renewed attention thanks to advancements in forensic science. Investigators are hopeful that this technology will finally provide the answers that have eluded them for nearly five decades.

The Victims and the Unsolved Mystery

The tragic events unfolded in 1974 when two sisters, whose names are being withheld out of respect for their family, were found murdered in St. Cloud. The case quickly became a source of immense grief and fear within the community, but despite a thorough initial investigation, the perpetrator remained unidentified. The lack of a resolution left a lingering sense of unease and a deep desire for justice.

Enter Herbert Notch: A Criminal History of Note

At the time of the murders, Herbert Notch was already a well-known figure in Central Minnesota, notorious for his extensive criminal history. While he was not initially considered a prime suspect, his past actions and the nature of the crimes have led investigators to revisit his potential involvement. Notch's criminal record is extensive, encompassing a range of offenses that have long cast a shadow over the region.

The Power of Modern DNA Analysis

The recent development hinges on the application of advanced DNA analysis techniques. Previously unavailable, these technologies can extract and analyze minute traces of DNA, even from samples that have degraded significantly over time. Physical evidence collected from the 1974 crime scene is now undergoing this rigorous testing. The hope is that a usable DNA profile can be obtained and compared against known samples.

Potential for a Definitive Link

If the DNA analysis yields a viable profile, investigators plan to compare it against samples from Herbert Notch. A match would provide compelling evidence linking him to the murders, potentially leading to his arrest and conviction decades after the crimes were committed. This would finally bring closure to the victims' families and the community that has long sought answers.

The Legal and Ethical Considerations

While the prospect of a resolution is exciting, investigators are proceeding with caution, mindful of the legal and ethical considerations involved in using DNA evidence from such a long-ago crime. Strict protocols are being followed to ensure the integrity of the analysis and to protect the rights of all parties involved. The process is meticulous and requires absolute certainty before any conclusions are drawn.

A Glimmer of Hope After Decades of Uncertainty

The renewed investigation and the application of cutting-edge DNA technology offer a glimmer of hope after decades of uncertainty. While the outcome remains uncertain, the possibility of finally solving this cold case and bringing justice to the victims and their families is a powerful motivator for those involved. The community watches with anticipation as this crucial stage of the investigation unfolds, hoping for a resolution that has been long awaited.

Recommendations
Recommendations