Mystery in Montauk: Manhattan Woman Found Dead on Boat, Police Investigate

2025-08-06
Mystery in Montauk: Manhattan Woman Found Dead on Boat, Police Investigate
ABC News

Montauk, NY – A tragic discovery has shaken the Long Island community as authorities have identified the woman found deceased on a docked boat in Montauk as Martha Nolan-O'Slatarra, a 33-year-old resident of Manhattan. The Suffolk County Police Department confirmed the identification on Wednesday, launching a full investigation into the circumstances surrounding her death.

The unsettling scene unfolded on Tuesday when police received a call regarding a deceased individual aboard a vessel in Montauk. Upon arrival, officers made the grim discovery and immediately initiated procedures to secure the scene and notify the appropriate authorities. The identity of the victim remained unknown initially, sparking speculation and concern among locals.

“We were informed of the situation on Tuesday and swiftly responded to the scene,” stated a police spokesperson. “After a thorough examination and verification process, we can confirm that the deceased is Martha Nolan-O'Slatarra, 33, of Manhattan. Our investigation is ongoing, and we are working diligently to piece together the events leading up to her death.”

Details surrounding the cause of death remain scarce, and police are being tight-lipped to protect the integrity of the investigation. They have confirmed that an autopsy is scheduled to be performed to determine the precise cause and manner of death. The investigation will involve interviews with individuals who may have had contact with Ms. Nolan-O'Slatarra prior to her death, as well as a comprehensive examination of the boat where she was found.

The news has sent ripples of sadness and concern through both the Montauk and Manhattan communities. Friends and acquaintances are struggling to comprehend the sudden loss, and many are offering condolences to Ms. Nolan-O'Slatarra's family and loved ones. Social media platforms have been flooded with messages of shock and disbelief.

“Martha was a vibrant and cherished member of our community,” said one acquaintance who wished to remain anonymous. “This is a devastating loss, and we are all heartbroken for her family.”

The Suffolk County Police Department is urging anyone with information related to this case to come forward and contact them. Even seemingly insignificant details could prove crucial in helping investigators uncover the truth. The department has set up a dedicated tip line for individuals to share information anonymously.

As the investigation continues, the focus remains on providing answers and closure to Ms. Nolan-O'Slatarra’s family and ensuring that those responsible for her death, if foul play is involved, are brought to justice. This case serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the importance of community support during times of tragedy.

Updates will be provided as the investigation progresses.

Recommendations
Recommendations